What the AMC tests in orthopaedics
Orthopaedics is a large area with many small topics. The exam does not ask you to fix fractures. It asks whether you can recognise the injury, choose the right imaging, spot the limb-threatening or life-threatening complication, and know which patients need urgent orthopaedic referral. Many stems are set in an emergency department or a GP clinic.
Questions come in four main types. Clinical decision rules: does this ankle or knee need an X-ray? Emergencies: compartment syndrome, open fracture, septic joint, cauda equina, a dislocated hip. Ageing and bone health: hip fracture, osteoporotic fracture, osteoarthritis. Common clinic problems: shoulder pain, carpal tunnel syndrome, hand injuries and sports injuries.
Australian clinical care standards shape the expected answers. The Australian Commission on Safety and Quality in Health Care has published standards for hip fracture care, low back pain and knee osteoarthritis. Each one discourages a common low-value practice, and the exam can test that.
- Decision rules: Ottawa ankle and knee rules, Canadian C-spine rule
- Emergencies: neurovascular compromise, compartment syndrome, open fractures, infection, cauda equina
- Older adults: hip fracture pathway, delirium, secondary fracture prevention
- Clinic: shoulder, hand, knee and back pain with red flag screening
High-yield fractures: hip, wrist, ankle and clavicle
Hip fracture is the core older-adult orthopaedic topic. The usual story is a fall, groin pain, inability to bear weight, and a shortened externally rotated leg. If the X-ray is normal but suspicion remains, MRI or CT is the next step, because an occult fracture is common. The ACSQHC Hip Fracture Care Clinical Care Standard expects early pain relief including a nerve block, assessment for delirium, surgery within 48 hours of presentation when appropriate, mobilisation the day after surgery and a plan to prevent the next fracture. Displaced intracapsular fractures are usually treated with arthroplasty because the blood supply to the femoral head is at risk. Extracapsular fractures are usually fixed.
The scaphoid is the wrist bone the exam loves. Tenderness in the anatomical snuffbox after a fall on an outstretched hand means scaphoid fracture until proven otherwise. The first X-ray is often normal. Immobilise the wrist and either repeat the X-ray in about 10 to 14 days or arrange CT or MRI. A missed fracture can lead to non-union and avascular necrosis of the proximal pole. Distal radius fractures are common in older women. Dorsal displacement is the classic Colles pattern and volar displacement the Smith pattern.
The Ottawa ankle rules say an ankle X-ray is needed if there is bone tenderness at the posterior edge or tip of either malleolus, or the patient cannot bear weight for four steps both immediately after the injury and in the department. Foot X-rays are needed for tenderness at the base of the fifth metatarsal or the navicular. A fracture of the fibula above the level of the ankle joint suggests injury to the syndesmosis and is often unstable. Always check for a proximal fibular fracture with a medial ankle injury.
Most midshaft clavicle fractures heal with a sling and early movement. Urgent referral is needed for an open fracture, skin tenting that may break through, or a neurovascular deficit.
- Suspected hip fracture with normal X-ray: MRI or CT
- Hip fracture: nerve block, delirium screen, surgery within 48 hours, mobilise early
- Snuffbox tenderness: immobilise and re-image even if the first X-ray is normal
- Ottawa ankle rules decide who needs an X-ray; most sprains do not
- Clavicle: sling for most; refer if skin threatened or neurovascular deficit
Orthopaedic emergencies: compartment syndrome, open fractures, dislocations and infection
Compartment syndrome is a surgical emergency. The early sign is pain out of proportion to the injury, especially pain on passive stretch of the muscles in the compartment. Pulses are usually still present and their loss is a late sign. It often follows a tibial fracture, a crush injury or a tight cast. The first steps are to remove or split the cast and dressings down to the skin, keep the limb at heart level rather than elevated, and call for urgent surgical review. Fasciotomy is the definitive treatment. Compartment pressure measurement can help if the picture is unclear, but should not delay surgery when the diagnosis is clinical.
Open fractures need IV antibiotics as soon as possible, tetanus protection, removal of gross contamination, a photograph of the wound, a saline-moistened dressing, splinting and urgent theatre for debridement. Therapeutic Guidelines provide the antibiotic choice, usually a first-generation cephalosporin such as cefazolin, with additions for heavy contamination.
Dislocations need neurovascular assessment before and after reduction. Anterior shoulder dislocation is the most common and can injure the axillary nerve, which causes numbness over the regimental badge area. Posterior shoulder dislocation follows seizures or electric shocks and is easily missed. Posterior hip dislocation after a dashboard injury can damage the sciatic nerve and needs urgent reduction to protect the blood supply to the femoral head. A knee dislocation can injure the popliteal artery even when it has reduced spontaneously, so vascular assessment is essential.
A hot, swollen, painful joint is septic arthritis until proven otherwise. Aspirate the joint before antibiotics and send fluid for Gram stain, culture, cell count and crystals. Then start IV antibiotics according to Therapeutic Guidelines, typically flucloxacillin to cover Staphylococcus aureus, with additional cover where MRSA or gonococcal infection is likely, and refer for washout. Osteomyelitis may present more slowly with bone pain and fever; MRI is the most useful imaging test.
- Pain on passive stretch: think compartment syndrome; split the cast to skin
- Open fracture: antibiotics, tetanus, dressing, splint, theatre
- Check and document neurovascular status before and after any reduction
- Hot swollen joint: aspirate before antibiotics, then treat and wash out
- Fever, petechiae and confusion a day or two after a long-bone fracture: fat embolism
Back pain, knee injuries and shoulder pain
Most acute low back pain is non-specific and settles. The ACSQHC Low Back Pain Clinical Care Standard asks clinicians to screen for serious causes, avoid routine imaging when there are no red flags, encourage activity and limit opioids. Red flags include features of cauda equina syndrome, a history of cancer, fever or immunosuppression, significant trauma or osteoporosis, and progressive neurological deficit.
Cauda equina syndrome causes saddle anaesthesia, new bladder or bowel dysfunction, and bilateral or severe leg symptoms. It needs an emergency MRI and urgent spinal surgical referral. Do not wait for urinary retention to develop before acting, because outcomes are better when decompression happens early.
Knee injuries follow patterns. A twisting injury with a pop and rapid swelling within hours suggests an anterior cruciate ligament tear and haemarthrosis; the Lachman test is the most sensitive bedside test. Locking or catching after a twist suggests a meniscal tear. A blow to the outside of the knee stresses the medial collateral ligament. The Ottawa knee rule helps decide who needs an X-ray.
In shoulder pain, a painful arc during abduction suggests rotator cuff disease. Global loss of movement, especially external rotation, in a middle-aged person with diabetes suggests adhesive capsulitis. Always consider referred pain from the neck, heart or diaphragm when the shoulder examination is normal.
- Non-specific low back pain: no routine imaging; advise activity
- Saddle anaesthesia or new bladder symptoms with back pain: emergency MRI
- Pop, rapid swelling and instability: ACL tear
- Loss of external rotation: adhesive capsulitis
Hand, wrist and elbow problems
Hand infections can destroy function quickly. Flexor tendon sheath infection gives a finger held in slight flexion, uniform swelling, tenderness along the sheath and severe pain on passive extension. It needs IV antibiotics and urgent surgical drainage. A fight bite over the knuckle from a punch to the mouth looks small but can enter the joint; it needs exploration and washout and antibiotics that cover mouth organisms, typically amoxicillin with clavulanic acid as per Therapeutic Guidelines.
Carpal tunnel syndrome causes numbness and tingling in the thumb, index, middle and half of the ring finger, often worse at night. Nerve conduction studies confirm it when the diagnosis is uncertain or surgery is planned. Splinting and steroid injection help mild cases; surgical release is offered for persistent symptoms or wasting. Other common hand conditions include trigger finger, Dupuytren contracture, de Quervain tenosynovitis (positive Finkelstein test) and ganglion cysts.
Mallet finger, an inability to straighten the tip of the finger after a blow, is treated with a splint that holds the end joint straight continuously for several weeks. An injury to the ulnar collateral ligament of the thumb after a fall while holding a ski pole needs assessment for instability. In the forearm, learn the two fracture-dislocation patterns: Monteggia is a fracture of the ulna with dislocation of the radial head, and Galeazzi is a fracture of the radius with disruption of the distal radioulnar joint. A radial head fracture may only show as a raised fat pad on an elbow X-ray.
- Flexor sheath infection: urgent surgical drainage
- Fight bite: explore, wash out, amoxicillin with clavulanic acid
- Night-time tingling in the lateral three and a half fingers: carpal tunnel
- Mallet finger: continuous extension splint
- Elbow fat pad sign: think occult radial head fracture
Bone tumours, osteoarthritis, sports injuries and fracture complications
Bone pain at night or at rest, especially in an older adult, needs investigation for malignancy. Metastases are far more common than primary bone tumours. The usual primaries are breast, prostate, lung, kidney and thyroid. Multiple myeloma causes lytic lesions, anaemia, renal impairment and hypercalcaemia. Primary bone sarcomas such as osteosarcoma mainly affect adolescents and young adults and present with pain and a mass near the knee.
The ACSQHC Osteoarthritis of the Knee Clinical Care Standard is a key Australian reference. It supports diagnosis on clinical grounds without routine imaging, education, exercise and weight management as the foundation of care, and it advises that arthroscopic surgery should not be used to treat knee osteoarthritis. Joint replacement is considered when symptoms remain severe despite good non-surgical care.
Sports injury questions include Achilles tendon rupture, which presents with a sudden snap in the calf and a positive Simmonds (calf squeeze) test, hamstring strains and stress fractures in runners. Fracture complications include fat embolism, venous thromboembolism, non-union, malunion, avascular necrosis and complex regional pain syndrome.
- Night pain or rest pain: investigate for tumour or infection
- Knee OA: exercise, education and weight loss first; no arthroscopy
- Sudden calf snap with positive calf squeeze test: Achilles rupture
- Long-bone fracture then hypoxia and petechiae: fat embolism syndrome
Australian practice differences and how to read the stems
The clinical care standards are the main difference from overseas training. Candidates from systems where imaging and arthroscopy are routine may pick these options by habit. In Australia, routine imaging for non-specific back pain and arthroscopy for knee osteoarthritis are considered low-value care. Hip fracture care is benchmarked through the Australian and New Zealand Hip Fracture Registry, so time to surgery, nerve blocks and delirium care are measured.
When you read an orthopaedic stem, look first for neurovascular status, skin integrity and signs of infection. Any of these changes the urgency. Then look at the mechanism and the exact site of tenderness, which usually tells you the injury. Finally, ask whether a decision rule applies. If the stem gives you the elements of the Ottawa ankle rule, the question is testing whether you know when not to X-ray.
In older patients, remember that the fall itself needs explaining. A hip fracture question may really be about syncope, a medication cause or osteoporosis treatment after the fracture.
- Check neurovascular status, skin and infection signs first
- Exact site of tenderness usually names the injury
- Apply decision rules before ordering imaging
- After a fragility fracture, start secondary fracture prevention
| Presentation | Likely diagnosis | Expected action |
|---|---|---|
| Fall, shortened externally rotated leg | Hip fracture | Nerve block, surgery within 48 hours |
| Snuffbox tenderness, normal X-ray | Possible scaphoid fracture | Immobilise, repeat X-ray or CT/MRI |
| Pain on passive stretch after tibial fracture | Compartment syndrome | Split cast to skin, urgent fasciotomy |
| Bone visible through wound | Open fracture | IV antibiotics, tetanus, theatre |
| Hot swollen knee, fever | Septic arthritis | Aspirate, then IV antibiotics and washout |
| Back pain, saddle numbness, urinary retention | Cauda equina syndrome | Emergency MRI and spinal surgery |
| Twisting injury, pop, rapid haemarthrosis | ACL tear | Lachman test, MRI, orthopaedic referral |
| Swollen finger, pain on passive extension | Flexor sheath infection | IV antibiotics, surgical drainage |
| Knuckle wound after punch | Fight bite | Explore and wash out, amoxicillin-clavulanate |
| Knee pain, morning stiffness under 30 minutes, age 65 | Knee osteoarthritis | Exercise, education, weight loss; no arthroscopy |
Worked examples in AMC style
Pick an answer to see why each option is right or wrong. These examples are written for this page; the bank holds the full set for orthopaedics & sports injuries.
Example 1
An 83-year-old woman is brought to the emergency department after a fall at home. She cannot bear weight and has severe right groin pain. Her right leg is shortened and externally rotated. An X-ray confirms a displaced intracapsular fracture of the right femoral neck. She is in pain despite IV morphine.
What is the most appropriate next step in her pain management?
-
Escalating opioids in an older patient increases the risk of delirium, respiratory depression and constipation.
-
NSAIDs carry risks of renal injury and bleeding in older adults and are not the preferred analgesic in hip fracture.
-
Skin traction is not recommended for pain relief in hip fracture and does not improve outcomes.
-
Correct. A regional nerve block such as a fascia iliaca block gives effective pain relief and reduces opioid needs, in line with the Hip Fracture Care Clinical Care Standard.
-
Patient-controlled analgesia can be hard for older or cognitively impaired patients and still relies on opioids alone.
Show answer and reasoning
Answer: D. Perform a fascia iliaca nerve block
- A. Escalating opioids in an older patient increases the risk of delirium, respiratory depression and constipation.
- B. NSAIDs carry risks of renal injury and bleeding in older adults and are not the preferred analgesic in hip fracture.
- C. Skin traction is not recommended for pain relief in hip fracture and does not improve outcomes.
- D. Correct. A regional nerve block such as a fascia iliaca block gives effective pain relief and reduces opioid needs, in line with the Hip Fracture Care Clinical Care Standard.
- E. Patient-controlled analgesia can be hard for older or cognitively impaired patients and still relies on opioids alone.
Hip fracture analgesia: offer a nerve block early to reduce opioids and delirium risk.
Based on: ACSQHC Hip Fracture Care Clinical Care Standard
Example 2
A 24-year-old man fell onto his outstretched right hand while playing football. He has pain on the radial side of the wrist and tenderness in the anatomical snuffbox. Wrist X-rays including scaphoid views are reported as normal. He is right-handed and works as a carpenter.
What is the most appropriate management?
-
Scaphoid fractures are often not visible at first. Reassurance risks a missed fracture and non-union.
-
Correct. Clinical suspicion of scaphoid fracture with a normal X-ray needs immobilisation and repeat imaging, either X-ray at 10 to 14 days or early CT or MRI.
-
There is no confirmed fracture or displacement. Surgery is not indicated at this stage.
-
A crepe bandage does not immobilise the wrist adequately while a fracture is possible.
-
Steroid injection has no role in an acute injury and could mask symptoms.
Show answer and reasoning
Answer: B. Immobilise and arrange repeat imaging
- A. Scaphoid fractures are often not visible at first. Reassurance risks a missed fracture and non-union.
- B. Correct. Clinical suspicion of scaphoid fracture with a normal X-ray needs immobilisation and repeat imaging, either X-ray at 10 to 14 days or early CT or MRI.
- C. There is no confirmed fracture or displacement. Surgery is not indicated at this stage.
- D. A crepe bandage does not immobilise the wrist adequately while a fracture is possible.
- E. Steroid injection has no role in an acute injury and could mask symptoms.
Snuffbox tenderness with a normal X-ray: treat as a fracture and re-image.
Based on: Australian emergency department fracture management practice
Example 3
A 46-year-old woman presents with two days of low back pain radiating down both legs. Since this morning she has had numbness around her anus and has had difficulty starting to pass urine. Examination shows reduced sensation in the perineum and reduced ankle reflexes on both sides. She has no fever.
What is the most appropriate next step?
-
Plain X-ray cannot show nerve root or cauda equina compression and delays diagnosis.
-
Conservative care is for non-specific back pain without red flags. She has red flags for cauda equina syndrome.
-
Correct. Saddle anaesthesia, bladder dysfunction and bilateral leg symptoms suggest cauda equina syndrome. She needs an emergency MRI and urgent spinal surgical review.
-
Outpatient referral is far too slow. Delay worsens bladder, bowel and sexual function outcomes.
-
Nerve conduction studies do not image compression and have no place in an emergency.
Show answer and reasoning
Answer: C. Emergency MRI of the lumbar spine
- A. Plain X-ray cannot show nerve root or cauda equina compression and delays diagnosis.
- B. Conservative care is for non-specific back pain without red flags. She has red flags for cauda equina syndrome.
- C. Correct. Saddle anaesthesia, bladder dysfunction and bilateral leg symptoms suggest cauda equina syndrome. She needs an emergency MRI and urgent spinal surgical review.
- D. Outpatient referral is far too slow. Delay worsens bladder, bowel and sexual function outcomes.
- E. Nerve conduction studies do not image compression and have no place in an emergency.
Back pain with saddle anaesthesia or new bladder symptoms: emergency MRI and spinal surgery, same day.
Based on: ACSQHC Low Back Pain Clinical Care Standard (red flags)
Quick recall
Tap a card to turn it over. If you can answer all eight without looking, move on to timed questions.
Where candidates lose marks
- Trusting the first X-ray
Scaphoid and hip fractures are often invisible at first. Strong clinical suspicion needs immobilisation and further imaging.
- Waiting for absent pulses
In compartment syndrome, pulses disappear late. Pain on passive stretch is the early warning.
- Antibiotics before aspiration
Starting antibiotics first can make joint cultures negative. Aspirate, then treat promptly.
- Imaging every back
Non-specific low back pain without red flags does not need imaging under Australian standards.
- Arthroscopy for knee osteoarthritis
Australian guidance is clear that arthroscopic washout or debridement does not help knee osteoarthritis.
How to study orthopaedics & sports injuries
Day 1: Learn hip fracture care, osteoporotic fractures and secondary prevention; do 15 questions.
Day 2: Study wrist, scaphoid, ankle, foot and clavicle injuries with the Ottawa rules.
Day 3: Cover compartment syndrome, open fractures, dislocations and fracture complications.
Day 4: Study septic arthritis, osteomyelitis, hand infections and hand conditions.
Day 5: Cover back pain red flags, cauda equina, knee and shoulder problems and bone tumours.
Day 6: Do a timed 40-question orthopaedic block and review each wrong option against this page.
Sources and further reading
Check the current edition of each guideline before your exam. This page is study material, not clinical advice.
- ACSQHC Hip Fracture Care Clinical Care Standard
- ACSQHC Low Back Pain Clinical Care Standard
- ACSQHC Osteoarthritis of the Knee Clinical Care Standard
- Therapeutic Guidelines: Antibiotic (bone and joint infections)
- Australian and New Zealand Hip Fracture Registry
- RACGP and Healthy Bones Australia: Osteoporosis management guideline